Old Fashioned Peanut Butter Pie Recipe - These Old Cookbooks (2024)

December 17, 2019February 17, 2022

As an Amazon Associate and member of other affiliate programs, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Old Fashioned Peanut Butter Pie is a from scratch pudding pie that has a decadent peanut butter flavor and smooth, creamy texture. Homemade peanut butter pie from scratch is easy as pie. You may never buy a boxed pudding mix again after making this easy pudding filling.

Old Fashioned Peanut Butter Pie Recipe

Cream pies are my hands-down favorite types of pie. My honest opinion is that a good dessert shouldn’t be ruined with fruit. EEK! I know; it’s very controversial. My favorite desserts have chocolate, butterscotch, caramel or peanut butter, and this particular pie falls in to the peanut butter category.

A homemade cream pie is a pudding or filling that is made on the stove top, and then poured into a pre-baked pie crust. Making this peanut butter pudding from scratch is a simple process. Not a fan of peanut butter pudding? Try our chocolate and vanilla pudding recipes.

Want to know a secret? Up to a few months ago, I was afraid of cream pies and homemade puddings. I thought it was hard or tricky. But, who knew that it is so simple. Since then, Real Lemon Meringue Pie and Amaretto Sugar Cream Pie have been on my dessert rotation.

Homemade Peanut Butter Pie from Scratch

The trick is to focus only on the pudding when it is on the stove top. Do not walk away. Do not start 1,000 other tasks at the same time. Instead, give your pudding 10 minutes of your time, and you will be rewarded with smooth, creamy, homemade, decadent pudding. You are welcome.

This old fashioned peanut butter pie recipe comes from my Extension Homemakers Cookbook from 1988. These ladies knew how to cook. If you see a vintage cookbook from a group of homemakers or a church at a garage sale or book store, snatch it up.

Peanut Butter Pie Ingredients

Egg Yolks

Milk (preferablly whole milk)

Sugar

Cornstarch

Salt

Peanut Butter

Vanilla Extract

Prepared Pie Crust

Cool Whip (optional)

Peanuts (optional)

How To Make Peanut Butter Pie from Scratch

Instructions:

1. In a small bowl, mix sugar, cornstarch and salt; set aside.
2. In a medium saucepan, add milk and egg yolks; whisk until smooth. Turn on heat to low.
3. Slowly add in the sugar mixture to the milk mixture.
4. Turn up the heat to medium, and whisk constantly until the mixture comes to a boil and thickens to a pudding consistency.
5. Remove from heat, and pour into a bowl. Press a layer of waxed paper over pudding and chill completely.
6. Once chilled, whip with a mixer until creamy; add peanut butter and vanilla and beat until smooth.
7. Pour into a pre-baked and cooled pie crust. If desired, top with whipped topping or homemade whipped cream.

For the full instructions for a homemade peanut butter cream pie, scroll to the bottom of this post.

Notes About Peanut Butter Cream Pie:

• This pie is an old fashioned peanut butter cream pie. It consists of making a homemade pudding on the stove. Once you’ve made homemade pudding, there’s no going back to the boxed kind.
• You can omit the pie crust and eat this as peanut butter pudding from scratch. Or try it with a chocolate graham cracker crust from the grocery store.
• If your peanut butter pudding has lumps, you can press it through a sieve to make smooth.
• Whipped cream or Cool Whip is optional. Try sprinkling the top with chopped peanuts or peanut butter chips for some extra pizzazz.
• Homemade puddings tend to form a skin. During the cooling stage, take a piece of waxed paper, and press it right up to the pudding to prevent this from happening to this peanut butter pie from scratch.
• Be sure to refrigerate this peanut butter cream pie from scratch.
• Love peanut butter? Try our Scotcheroos , Salted Peanut Squares, and Sea Salted Peanut Butter Cookies with Chocolate Chunks.

Our Favorite Old Fashioned Pie Recipes

Try some of our other favorite pie recipes:

Grandma’s Rhubarb Pie

Zucchini Pie

Impossible Pumpkin Pie

Spaghetti Pie (hey, it’s a pie too!)

Real Lemon Meringue Pie

Amaretto Sugar Cream Pie

Grandma’s Pumpkin Chiffon Pie

Linking up to Weekend Potluck.